Small Cheesecakes with a Great Flavor Combination

Four chocolate pumpkin cheesecake cupcakesA number of years ago I was asked to do the rehearsal dinner for a gluten-intolerant bride.  I wanted to make a dessert that she could eat, and I was told that she liked chocolate and pumpkin.  Hmmm.  I hadn’t ever really thought of that flavor combination, but it sounded pretty good.  So I went online to see what ideas were out there, and I came up with a pumpkin-chocolate pie, basically a two-layer cheesecake baked as a pie.  It had a crumb crust, which I couldn’t use, so I needed a way to make it easy to slice and eat without one.  That’s how I came up with the idea of making it in muffin cups, and I called them “timbales.”  Sounded pretty classy, and they were a great hit.  Awhile after the dinner we were told that what the bride actually liked was raw pumpkin from the can mixed with chocolate chips!  (I could have saved myself a lot of work by just serving a bowlful of that combination.)  You’ll note that the picture doesn’t have the muffin liners, and that the timbales look a bit messy.  That’s because I discovered at 6:15 AM that I didn’t have any liners. They are definitely easier and neater with the liners.  Since I’m not making these gluten-free any more, I’ve added the chocolate-graham-cracker crust.